Skip to content

Traps and myths

Learning styles: a popular idea the evidence does not support

How learning works · Published · Evidence: Myth · About this guide

People do have preferences about how they like to learn, such as pictures or listening. The claim behind learning styles, that you learn more when teaching matches that preference, has found little support: a 2008 review found virtually no evidence for it among studies designed to test it, and a later small experiment matching audiobooks and e-texts to preferences found no measurable difference [1][2].

Are you a visual learner, an auditory learner or a hands-on one? Many people have taken a questionnaire that sorts them like this. In surveys of educators from 18 countries, about nine in ten agreed that matching teaching to a student's learning style improves learning, although most of those surveys were small and their questions could be read in more than one way [3]. Tested with the right kind of experiment, the idea has found little support.

Are you a visual, auditory or kinesthetic learner?

You may well prefer one of these ways in, and a questionnaire can put a name to that preference. What the name does not tell you is how you learn best. In one of the studies below, matching the format to people's preference made no measurable difference to how much they understood [2]; in another, pictures were remembered better than words even by people who preferred words [4].

What does a learning-styles test measure?

It measures preferences, which are real. Whether teaching should be matched to them is a separate claim. "Learning styles" covers many different questionnaires and models [1]. A well-known one, VARK, scores people on how much they prefer visual material, listening, reading and writing, or learning by doing [5]. Others ask whether you prefer words or pictures, or, like the VAK model, sort people into visual, auditory and kinesthetic learners.

Two claims are easy to blur. The first, that people have preferences about how information is presented, is true: asked, children and adults will say how they like to learn [1]. The second is that you learn more when teaching matches your preference, so a "visual learner" should get pictures and an "auditory learner" should listen. Researchers call this the meshing hypothesis, and it is the most common form of the idea [1]. The first claim does not prove the second.

What kind of evidence would show that it works?

In 2008, four psychologists were asked to review whether teaching by learning style was backed by scientific evidence [1]. They set out what a convincing test would need:

  1. Sort learners by their style, for example into "visual" and "auditory" groups.
  2. Within each group, assign people at random to different teaching methods, for example a picture-based lesson or a spoken one.
  3. Give everyone the same test afterwards.
  4. Look for a crossover: the visual group learns best from the picture lesson, and the auditory group learns best from the spoken one.

The crossover is the key point. If pictures help everyone, that is a fact about pictures, not about styles. If self-described visual learners do better whatever the lesson, that is a fact about those people, not about matching. Only a crossover shows that the best method depends on the learner's style.

Crossing lines, an illustration (not data), beside measured scores: those who preferred reading scored higher with both formats.

Matching the format to a learning style: the crossover it would need, and what was measured (Rogowsky et al. 2015)

The lines are an illustration, not data: the crossover a learning-styles effect would need, with each group doing best in the format it prefers. The bars are measured data from Rogowsky, Calhoun and Tallal (2015): comprehension scores out of 48 on a written test taken straight after listening to an audiobook or reading the same text as an e-text, for adults who preferred listening or reading. The bars show no crossover, and the interaction was not significant at this test or two weeks later. About ten people per group: group averages from one small study, not a prediction for any one learner.

Pattern: Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer & Bjork (2008). Data: Rogowsky, Calhoun & Tallal (2015), Journal of Educational Psychology 107(1), Table 3. [1][2]

Data table
Matching the format to a learning style: the crossover it would need, and what was measured (Rogowsky et al. 2015)
PreferenceAudiobookE-text
Prefer listening29.8231.40
Prefer reading34.6034.20
  • The scores are correct answers out of 48 on a written test taken straight after the listening or reading (the first test).
  • The four groups had 11 people (prefer listening, audiobook) and 10 people each (the other three): only the adults whose questionnaire showed a clear preference for listening or for reading.
  • Two weeks later the same test gave 26.64 and 28.10 (prefer listening) and 32.70 and 31.80 (prefer reading), audiobook first: again no crossover, and the interaction was not significant.
  • The lines have no values: they show only the pattern Pashler and colleagues (2008) set as the test that matching would have to pass.

What did researchers find when they tested it?

The 2008 review found that, although the learning-styles literature is enormous, very few studies had used a design able to test the idea. In those that had, the reviewers found virtually no evidence of the crossover, and several results flatly contradicted it. They concluded that there was no adequate evidence base for building learning-style assessments into general teaching, and that limited resources for education would be better spent on practices with a strong evidence base [1].

Later studies followed the recipe. In one, 121 adults with a college degree filled in a learning-style questionnaire and took a listening and a reading comprehension test [2]. Among the 68 with a clear preference, those who preferred listening did not understand spoken text better, and those who preferred reading scored higher on both tests, although every question was answered in writing, which the authors note may have favoured them. Some of the same people were then assigned at random to learn the preface and one chapter of a non-fiction book (about 3,200 words) as an audiobook or as an e-text, and were tested straight afterwards and two weeks later. Matching the version to the preference made no measurable difference at either test. The groups in this part were small, about ten people each, so this study alone cannot rule out a small effect.

A study of 426 university anatomy students asked them in a survey how they studied outside class [5]. Most did not report studying in the ways their VARK result suggested, their VARK scores were not related to how they did in the course, and those whose reported habits fitted their VARK result did no better. Some particular study habits went with better grades, whatever the student's style. This was a survey, not an experiment, so it shows associations, not causes.

Why does the idea feel so convincing?

One experiment suggests an answer [4]. Fifty-two female university students filled in a questionnaire about whether they preferred words or pictures. They then learned a list of word pairs and a list of picture pairs and, for half of the pairs, rated right after studying each one how well they expected to remember it. The more someone preferred words, the higher they rated their learning of the words; the more someone preferred pictures, the higher they rated the pictures. Actual recall did not follow these preferences. On average, recall was higher for the pictures than for the words, 51% against 37%, and that held for the students who preferred words too. Their preference went with how learning felt, not with how much they learned.

How easy something feels while you study can be a misleading guide to how well you will remember it; the article on illusions of knowing looks at this trap.

Is dual coding just learning styles under another name?

No, although the two are often confused. Dual coding theory, developed by the psychologist Allan Paivio, proposes that the mind works with two linked kinds of representation: words, and mental images, which in the theory cover sounds and actions as well as pictures. According to the theory, the two add up, so material held both ways is remembered better than words alone [6]. The practical advice that follows is to pair words with a relevant picture or diagram.

The difference lies in who the advice is for. Learning styles says: give each person the format they prefer. Dual coding says: give everyone both, because they complement each other [7]. The picture study above fits this: pictures were remembered better than words even by the students who preferred words [4].

Dual coding has limits too:

  • For an explanation, the picture has to show how it works. In experiments with short texts explaining how a device works, diagrams showing both its parts and the steps of how it works improved understanding and problem solving; other kinds of illustration did not. The benefit appeared mainly for students who knew little about the topic beforehand [8].
  • More is not automatically better. Each extra picture adds something to process, and vivid but irrelevant detail can distract [7].
  • Picturing what you read is not enough on its own. A large review rated forming mental images while reading as a technique of low utility: it helped some students on some tasks, under limited conditions [9].

What can you do instead?

These are reasonable ways to use the findings, not guarantees:

  • Match the format to the material, not to a label. A process with steps is often easier to show than to describe; a pronunciation has to be heard.
  • Pair words with a picture that explains. A labelled diagram of how the parts connect does more than a decorative image.
  • Sketch it yourself. In laboratory experiments with undergraduates, words that people drew were later recalled better than words they wrote out [10]. Those were word lists; how far this carries over to longer material is less clear.
  • Use methods that help learners broadly. A large review rated practice testing and spreading study over time as highly useful, partly because they help learners of different ages and abilities [9]. The articles on retrieval practice and spaced practice explain both.
  • Treat a preference as comfort, not as a limit. If you enjoy listening, listening is a fine way in. Just do not skip the diagram, or the self-test, because a questionnaire called you an "auditory learner".
  • Judge a method by a later test, not by how it felt.

What the research does not say

  • It does not say everyone learns in the same way. People differ in what they already know and in specific abilities, and they have real preferences [1][8]. What lacks support is the step from a style label to a better way of teaching that person.
  • It does not rule out every possible kind of matching. The 2008 review stressed that many versions of learning styles have not been tested at all [1].
  • It does not say pictures beat words for everything. The benefit depends on the picture, the material and what the learner already knows [8].
  • It does not mean every lesson should use every format. Adding formats can add effort without adding understanding [7].
  • It is not about disabilities. Adjustments for a hearing or vision impairment, or for a diagnosed learning difficulty, are a separate matter from learning styles. This article does not cover them; a qualified professional can advise.
  • It does not show how often teaching is actually matched to styles. The surveys asked what educators believe and, in a few small ones, what they say they do; none observed what actually happens in classrooms, and most used small convenience samples [3].

Sources

Every source the guide cites

  1. [1] Pashler, H., McDaniel, M., Rohrer, D., & Bjork, R. (2008). Learning styles: Concepts and evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 9(3), 105–119. review · doi.org/10.1111/j.1539-6053.2009.01038.x
  2. [2] Rogowsky, B. A., Calhoun, B. M., & Tallal, P. (2015). Matching learning style to instructional method: Effects on comprehension. Journal of Educational Psychology, 107(1), 64–78. experiment · doi.org/10.1037/a0037478
  3. [3] Newton, P. M., & Salvi, A. (2020). How common is belief in the learning styles neuromyth, and does it matter? A pragmatic systematic review. Frontiers in Education, 5, 602451. review · doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2020.602451
  4. [4] Knoll, A. R., Otani, H., Skeel, R. L., & Van Horn, K. R. (2017). Learning style, judgements of learning, and learning of verbal and visual information. British Journal of Psychology, 108(3), 544–563. experiment · doi.org/10.1111/bjop.12214
  5. [5] Husmann, P. R., & O'Loughlin, V. D. (2019). Another nail in the coffin for learning styles? Disparities among undergraduate anatomy students' study strategies, class performance, and reported VARK learning styles. Anatomical Sciences Education, 12(1), 6–19. observational study · doi.org/10.1002/ase.1777
  6. [6] Clark, J. M., & Paivio, A. (1991). Dual coding theory and education. Educational Psychology Review, 3(3), 149–210. review · doi.org/10.1007/BF01320076
  7. [7] Weinstein, Y., Madan, C. R., & Sumeracki, M. A. (2018). Teaching the science of learning. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 3(1), 2. review · doi.org/10.1186/s41235-017-0087-y
  8. [8] Mayer, R. E., & Gallini, J. K. (1990). When is an illustration worth ten thousand words? Journal of Educational Psychology, 82(4), 715–726. experiment · doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.82.4.715
  9. [9] Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques: Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58. review · doi.org/10.1177/1529100612453266
  10. [10] Wammes, J. D., Meade, M. E., & Fernandes, M. A. (2016). The drawing effect: Evidence for reliable and robust memory benefits in free recall. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 69(9), 1752–1776. experiment · doi.org/10.1080/17470218.2015.1094494

This guide is general information about learning research for students, not medical advice.