Skip to content

Traps and myths

The illusion of competence: when studying feels better than it works

How learning works · Published · Evidence: Strong · About this guide

An illusion of competence, or of knowing, is feeling that you know something better than you do. It often comes from fluency: a page you have just reread looks familiar and reads smoothly, and that ease is easily mistaken for learning, a fluency illusion [1][2]. In one experiment, students who reread a passage were surer they would remember it, yet a week later recalled less than students who had practised recalling it (40% vs 61%) [3].

You read a chapter for the second time and it goes smoothly. The terms look familiar, and you think: I know this. A week later, facing a blank page, much of it does not come back. The feeling was real, but it measured the wrong thing. Researchers call this an illusion of knowing, or of competence. This article covers where such illusions come from, why two popular study habits rate low, and how to check what you know.

Where does the feeling of knowing come from?

We cannot look inside our own memory, so we infer how well we know something from cues. One review compares these judgments to a speedometer, which infers speed from how fast the wheels turn, rather than a thermometer, which reads temperature directly [2]. One important cue is fluency: how easily a text reads or an answer comes to mind.

Fluency is often a fair guide, because well-learned material does come to mind easily. But it also comes from things unrelated to lasting memory, such as having read the page a minute ago or having the answer in front of you. Cues that say little about memory can sway the feeling too, even the size of the print. In one series of experiments, people expected to recall words in large type better than words in small type, and still did after being told that print size has little effect on memory, yet font size made little difference to what they recalled [4]. Researchers still debate whether this happens because large print is easier to read or because people believe it is easier to remember.

Psychologists Elizabeth and Robert Bjork describe the deeper problem as the gap between performance and learning. Performance is what you can do right now, during study. Learning is the lasting change that shows up later, and current performance can be a poor guide to it [1]. In their account, a memory has two strengths: how easily it comes to mind at the moment, and how deeply it is rooted in what you already know. What raises the first fastest is not what builds the second best, so reading today's ease as lasting learning leads you to prefer the weaker way of studying.

Why does rereading feel like learning?

When you reread, the text is familiar, so it reads more fluently, and that fluency is easy to mistake for understanding [1]. Rereading also shows you the answers. On a test they will be missing, and something that seems obvious next to its answer can be hard to produce without it [2].

One experiment shows how far feeling and result can drift apart [3]. Students learned a short factual passage. One group read it in four study periods, about 14 read-throughs in all. Another read it in one period and then spent three periods writing down everything they could remember, with no feedback. (The recall periods were longer than the reading periods; a first experiment that gave both the same time found the same reversal.) The rereaders were more confident that they would remember the passage a week later (4.8 against 4.0 on a 1-to-7 scale). Of the students tested five minutes after studying, the rereaders recalled more: 83% against 71%. Of those tested a week later, the order was reversed: 61% for practising recall, 40% for rereading.

Bar chart: after 5 minutes the rereaders recalled most (83% vs 71%); after a week the recallers did (61% vs 40%).

Rereading or recalling: ideas remembered after 5 minutes and after a week (Roediger & Karpicke 2006)

Measured data from Roediger and Karpicke (2006), Experiment 2. Five minutes after studying, the students who had spent four study periods reading the passage recalled the most of its ideas (83%); a week later they recalled the least (40%), while those who had read it once and recalled it three times recalled 61%. The readers were also the surest, on a 1–7 scale, that they would remember it. Each recall bar is a separate group of 30 students; group averages from one study, not a prediction for any one learner.

Data: Roediger & Karpicke (2006), Psychological Science 17(3), Experiment 2, p. 252 and Table 2. [3]

Data table
Rereading or recalling: ideas remembered after 5 minutes and after a week (Roediger & Karpicke 2006)
What was measuredFour study periodsThree study periods, one recall testOne study period, three recall tests
Share of the passage's ideas recalled: After 5 minutes83%78%71%
Share of the passage's ideas recalled: After a week40%56%61%
Expected recall a week later (1–7): Rating after studying4.84.24.0
  • Study periods lasted 5 minutes and recall tests 10 minutes. Experiment 1, which gave reading and recalling the same time, showed the same reversal.
  • After a week, the authors call the difference between one and three recall tests (56% and 61%) marginal.
  • The rating asked how well the students thought they would remember the passage in a week (1 = not very well, 7 = very well), at the end of the study session.

Do rereading and highlighting work?

A large review of ten common study techniques rated both rereading and highlighting as "low utility" [5]. In that review, low utility does not mean useless. It means the benefits are narrow, poorly established or smaller than those of the alternatives.

Rereading does help compared with reading once, especially when the second reading comes after a gap. When it is all done in one sitting, most of the gain comes from the second reading, and its benefit for understanding, as opposed to remembering, is less clear. In direct comparisons it came out behind practice testing, self-explanation and asking yourself why a fact is true, which the reviewers named as the main reason for its low rating [5].

Highlighting, as students usually do it, did not help beyond plain reading in most of the studies the review covered. It may help people who know enough to pick out what matters, or with difficult texts. One study, which the reviewers said needed replicating, found that students who underlined a history chapter and later reviewed their marked copy did worse on questions that required drawing inferences across the text [5]. A later meta-analysis of 36 articles found a modest average benefit of students' own highlighting on memory tests compared with reading alone, but no reliable benefit for comprehension or for school-age students [6]. Its benefit was measured against reading, not against testing yourself.

How common are these habits?

In a survey of 177 students at a selective US university, 84% listed rereading as a study strategy and 55% named it as their main one. Only 11% described practising recall, and 1% named it as their main strategy. The students were then asked what they would do after reading a textbook chapter once. When 101 of them had to choose between restudying the chapter and trying to recall it with no chance to look back, 57% chose to restudy and 18% to recall. When the other 76 could reread after recalling, 42% chose to test themselves, about as many as chose to reread (41%). In both versions, more of those who chose testing wanted to check what they knew than believed that recalling would itself help them learn: narrowly in the first (10 students against 8), clearly in the second (23 against 2) [7]. The authors suggest that illusions of competence help explain such choices.

Why do the better methods feel worse?

The Bjorks call a group of these conditions desirable difficulties: spacing study sessions apart, mixing topics instead of practising one at a time, varying the conditions of practice, and testing yourself instead of rereading [1]. Each slows visible progress during study yet tends to improve long-term retention, and because they feel harder, people often judge them worse. In a study with paintings, 78% of participants were better at identifying new paintings by artists they had studied mixed together with other artists' work, yet 78% said keeping each artist's paintings together had worked as well or better [8]. Cramming feels efficient for the same reason; the article on why cramming fails follows what it costs later.

The word "desirable" matters. Many difficulties are simply unhelpful, and a difficulty stops helping when the learner lacks the background knowledge or skills to respond to it [1]. Hard-to-read print is an example. A review of these illusions reported a study in which awkward fonts improved learning [2], but a later meta-analysis of 25 articles with 3,135 participants found no effect of hard-to-read text on recall or transfer; it only made people judge that they had learned less and spend longer studying [9]. What seems to help is effort spent recalling and making sense of the material, not effort as such [1].

How can you check what you really know?

Reasonable ways to apply the findings, not tested recipes:

  • Close the material and try to recall it. Write or say what you remember, then compare. Going back over a chapter is a poor way to judge what you will recall later; trying to answer questions on it shows what you have and have not learned [1].
  • Judge after a short delay, from a cue alone. In lab studies with word pairs, people became much better at telling which pairs they would and would not remember when they judged a while after studying, seeing only the first word of each pair, so that they had to test their memory [2].
  • Reread after a recall attempt, not instead of one. A test can make the study that follows it more effective [1]. Use the text to find and correct what you missed; the article on feedback and mistakes explains why that step matters.
  • If you highlight, mark little. In one study, students limited to underlining one sentence per paragraph recalled more of a science text than students who did not underline; in another, the same limit helped students remember what they had underlined but not the text as a whole [5].
  • Judge a study method by a later test, not by how smooth it felt.

What the research does not say

  • It does not say rereading and highlighting are worthless. Both helped memory compared with a single plain reading in some conditions [5][6]. They rate low mainly because other methods do more.
  • It does not say your sense of knowing is usually wrong. Whether you can recall something is an important cue, and often a fair one [2]. It misleads when the ease comes from the situation, such as the answer on the page or a recent reading, and judgments can also be swayed by cues such as the size of the print [2][4].
  • It does not say harder study is better study. Difficulty that adds no recalling or sense-making, such as hard-to-read print, showed no benefit [9].
  • It does not measure your own judgment. The findings are group averages, mostly from university students in lab settings with word lists and short passages. When the review was written, no experiment had tested rereading in a real course [5].
  • It does not mean something is wrong with you. The survey was of students at a highly selective university, and the review notes that teachers can make the same mistake, assuming that what their students know today they will still know next week [7][2].

Sources

Every source the guide cites

  1. [1] Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In M. A. Gernsbacher, R. W. Pew, L. M. Hough, & J. R. Pomerantz (Eds.), Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society (pp. 56–64). New York: Worth Publishers. book chapter
  2. [2] Bjork, R. A., Dunlosky, J., & Kornell, N. (2013). Self-regulated learning: Beliefs, techniques, and illusions. Annual Review of Psychology, 64(1), 417–444. review · doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-113011-143823
  3. [3] Roediger, H. L., III, & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249–255. experiment · doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01693.x
  4. [4] Rhodes, M. G., & Castel, A. D. (2008). Memory predictions are influenced by perceptual information: Evidence for metacognitive illusions. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 137(4), 615–625. experiment · doi.org/10.1037/a0013684
  5. [5] Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., & Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques: Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58. review · doi.org/10.1177/1529100612453266
  6. [6] Ponce, H. R., Mayer, R. E., & Méndez, E. E. (2022). Effects of learner-generated highlighting and instructor-provided highlighting on learning from text: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review, 34(2), 989–1024. meta-analysis · doi.org/10.1007/s10648-021-09654-1
  7. [7] Karpicke, J. D., Butler, A. C., & Roediger, H. L., III (2009). Metacognitive strategies in student learning: Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own? Memory, 17(4), 471–479. observational study · doi.org/10.1080/09658210802647009
  8. [8] Kornell, N., & Bjork, R. A. (2008). Learning concepts and categories: Is spacing the "enemy of induction"? Psychological Science, 19(6), 585–592. experiment · doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02127.x
  9. [9] Xie, H., Zhou, Z., & Liu, Q. (2018). Null effects of perceptual disfluency on learning outcomes in a text-based educational context: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review, 30(3), 745–771. meta-analysis · doi.org/10.1007/s10648-018-9442-x

This guide is general information about learning research for students, not medical advice.